Cloud-based Data Warehousing: Amazon Redshift vs. Snowflake vs. GCP BigQuery

Overview

When it comes to cloud-based data warehousing, there are three major players in the market: Amazon Redshift, Snowflake, and Google Cloud Platform (GCP). Each platform has unique features and capabilities, and choosing the right one for your organization can be a challenge. In this blog, we’ll look closer at Redshift, Snowflake, and GCP and compare them based on key factors like pricing, scalability, and ease of use.

Snowflake

Snowflake is a cloud-based data warehousing solution known for its scalability and ease of use. It’s designed to be simple for non-technical users but powerful enough for advanced analytics and machine learning. One of the key features of Snowflake is its ability to separate storage and compute, which makes it easy to scale up or down as needed. Snowflake also offers a variety of pricing options, including on-demand pricing, which allows you to pay only for the resources you use.

Source: altexsoft 

Pros:

• Scalable and easy to use
• Separation of storage and compute
• Good support for semi-structured data

Cons:

• More expensive than Redshift
• Limited integration with other cloud services
• Limited support for complex queries

Google Cloud Platform(BigQuery)

Source: Google Cloud 

Google Cloud Platform (GCP) is a cloud computing platform from Google that offers various services, including a data warehousing solution called BigQuery. BigQuery is designed to be fast and scalable, capable of handling structured and semi-structured data. One of the key advantages of BigQuery is its integration with other GCP services, like Cloud Storage and Cloud Machine Learning Engine, which makes it easy to move data in and out of the warehouse. GCP also offers a variety of pricing options, including on-demand pricing and flat-rate pricing, which allows you to pay a fixed monthly fee for a certain amount of usage.

Pros:

• Good support for semi-structured data
• Integration with other GCP services
• Good support for machine learning

Cons:

• More expensive than Redshift
• Limited customization options
• Limited support for complex queries

Amazon Redshift

Source: intermix.io 

Amazon Redshift is a cloud-based data warehousing solution by Amazon Web Services (AWS). It’s designed to be fast, scalable, and cost-effective, making it a popular choice for companies of all sizes. One of the biggest advantages of Redshift is its integration with other AWS services, like Amazon S3 and Lambda, which makes it easy to move data in and out of the warehouse. Amazon Redshift also offers a variety of pricing options, including on-demand pricing and reserved instance pricing, which allows you to save money by committing to a certain amount of usage.

Pros:

• Integration with other AWS services
• Variety of pricing options
• Good for organizations already using AWS

Cons:

• Limited support for semi-structured data
• Scaling can be challenging
• Limited support for machine learning

Price comparison

Snowflake

Snowflake’s pricing is based on the data storage and computing resources used. Snowflake offers three pricing models: On-demand, Snowflake Standard Edition, and Snowflake Enterprise Edition.

The On-demand pricing model allows users to pay for their computing resources hourly. The Snowflake Standard Edition provides additional features such as multi-cluster warehousing and enhanced data sharing. The Snowflake Enterprise Edition provides additional features, such as advanced security and compliance features.

GCP (BigQuery)

BigQuery’s pricing is based on the amount of data processed and stored data. BigQuery offers two pricing models: On-demand and Flat-rate.

The On-demand pricing model allows users to pay for their computing resources hourly. The Flat-rate pricing model provides a fixed monthly cost for a set amount of computing resources.

Amazon Redshift

Amazon Redshift’s pricing is based on the size of the cluster and the number of hours it runs. Amazon Redshift offers three pricing models: On-demand, Reserved, and Concurrency scaling.

The On-demand pricing model allows users to pay for their computing resources hourly. The Reserved pricing model allows users to reserve computing resources for one to three years at a discounted price. Concurrency scaling allows users to add additional clusters to handle increased query loads.

Conclusion

Choosing the right data warehousing solution for your organization depends on various factors, including your budget, data needs, and technical expertise. If you’re already using AWS, Redshift might be your best choice, thanks to its integration with other AWS services and its various pricing options. If you’re looking for a scalable and easy-to-use solution, Snowflake might be the way to go, thanks to its separation of storage and compute and its support for semi-structured data. And if you’re looking for a solution tightly integrated with other cloud services, like machine learning, GCP’s BigQuery might be your best option.

About CloudThat