Choosing the Right Amazon S3 Bucket Type

Over the past few years, Amazon S3 has grown well beyond its original role as a basic object storage solution. In response to increasing demands for high-performance, scalable, and intelligent data systems, AWS has introduced specialized bucket types designed for distinct use cases—from high-speed data analytics to ultra-low-latency edge computing and AI-powered semantic search. This evolution reflects a broader industry movement toward data-centric architectures, where storage plays a more active role in driving performance, security, and insight. The addition of Directory Buckets, Table Buckets, and Vector Buckets which is complementing the traditional General Purpose Buckets also represents a major leap in S3’s flexibility and power. These new bucket types offer fine-tuned performance, tighter access control, and deeper integration with analytics and machine learning tools. In this blog, we’ll break down each type to help you determine which is best suited to your workload, along with key details on their limitations, naming rules, access methods, and monitoring capabilities.

1. General Purpose Bucket:

General Purpose buckets are the standard and most utilized storage type in Amazon S3, known for their adaptability across a wide variety of use cases. They are well-suited for storing everything from backups and media content to static website files, application logs, and large-scale data lake assets. Designed for high durability and availability, these buckets span multiple Availability Zones and are compatible with all S3 storage classes—except for S3 Express One Zone. This makes them a solid choice for both frequently accessed and infrequently used data, depending on your lifecycle configuration.

These buckets are built to scale massively, with each AWS account allowed to create up to 10,000 buckets by default (expandable upon request). There are no fixed limits on storage capacity or the number of objects within a bucket, making them ideal for enterprise-level deployments.

Naming requirements dictate that bucket names must be globally unique within a region and follow certain conventions: lowercase letters, numbers, and hyphens only. Once a bucket is created, its name and region are fixed, ensuring consistent DNS resolution and routing behaviour.

By default, General Purpose buckets are private. Access can be managed through IAM policies, bucket-level policies, Access Points, or Access Control Lists (ACLs). AWS also recommends keeping Block Public Access enabled, which is turned on by default to help prevent unintended data exposure. Ownership settings can be adjusted to manage access more effectively, especially in shared or cross-account environments.

On the observability front, these buckets integrate with Amazon CloudWatch for metrics, AWS CloudTrail for auditing API activity, and S3 Storage Lens for usage insights. Additionally, features like server access logging, S3 Inventory, and IAM Access Analyzer support security monitoring and compliance enforcement.

Overall, General Purpose buckets strike a strong balance between scalability, performance, and security—making them the go-to choice for most storage needs within the AWS ecosystem.

2. Directory Bucket:

Directory Buckets are a newer feature in Amazon S3, purpose-built for scenarios that demand extremely low latency, high throughput, and location-specific data processing. Unlike traditional General Purpose buckets, these are bound to a particular Availability Zone or Local Zone, enabling data access in under 10 milliseconds. This makes them ideal for edge workloads, near-real-time data processing, and applications with burst traffic patterns that benefit from data locality. They are exclusively compatible with the S3 Express One Zone storage class, optimized for fast, zone-specific read/write performance.

To ensure predictable and consistent performance, Directory Buckets come with default service limits. AWS accounts can create up to 100 Directory Buckets, and each bucket can handle up to 200,000 read transactions per second. There’s no cap on object count, but one notable behaviour is that if a bucket sees no activity (read or write) for 90 days, it transitions into an inactive state. While the stored data remains intact, access attempts will return HTTP 503 errors until the bucket is reactivated.

Naming requirements for Directory Buckets are distinct—they must include the Availability Zone ID, using a structure like bucket-name–zone-id–x-s3. This naming scheme reflects the bucket’s geographic scope and supports latency-optimized routing.

From a security standpoint, Directory Buckets are always private. Public access is permanently blocked and cannot be enabled. ACLs are not supported, encouraging the use of more robust access management through IAM policies or S3 Access Points. These mechanisms allow for detailed access controls and are especially effective in multi-user or multi-tenant environments.

Monitoring tools such as AWS CloudTrail and Amazon CloudWatch can be used to log and analyze activity, while S3 Storage Lens and Access Analyzer provide insights into usage patterns and policy compliance. However, it’s essential that access policies align with the strict private-only configuration of these buckets.

In summary, for workloads where rapid access, data residency, and high-volume throughput are critical, Directory Buckets offer a highly specialized and efficient alternative to general-purpose object storage.

3. Table Bucket:

Table Buckets are Amazon S3’s solution for storing and managing structured, tabular datasets directly within the S3 ecosystem. Built to work with the Apache Iceberg table format, these buckets are designed for modern analytics use cases that demand version control, schema evolution, and atomic operations. They are particularly well-suited for applications like real-time analytics, streaming data processing, and transactional workloads that need robust metadata and strong consistency.

Each AWS account can provision up to 10 Table Buckets per Region, and within each bucket, you can manage up to 10,000 individual tables. These tables integrate seamlessly with a range of AWS analytics services, including Amazon Athena, AWS Glue, Redshift, and Apache Spark, making it easier to query and analyze large datasets without needing external data lakes or complex transformation pipelines.

Table Buckets follow a different naming and identification convention, using Amazon Resource Names (ARNs) under the s3tables namespace. Access is tightly controlled—public access is not permitted, and ACLs are not supported. Permissions must be defined using IAM identity policies or resource-based policies, offering fine-grained control over which users or roles can perform actions on specific tables or buckets.

Observability and compliance are fully supported through CloudTrail for auditing API activity and CloudWatch for capturing metrics related to query performance and resource usage. Additional tools like S3 Storage Lens and IAM Access Analyzer further assist with tracking storage usage and validating security posture.

If you’re building data lakes or warehouse-style solutions that require strong table semantics and scalable, structured storage, Table Buckets are a powerful and natively integrated option in Amazon S3.

4. Vector Bucket:

Vector Buckets, currently in preview, are an innovative addition to S3 aimed at machine learning and AI-driven applications that rely on vector embeddings. These embeddings—mathematical representations of data such as images, text, or audio—enable powerful similarity search and semantic retrieval capabilities. Vector Buckets are specifically optimized for storing, indexing, and querying these high-dimensional vectors with low latency.

Designed for workloads like recommendation engines, intelligent search systems, and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) for LLMs, Vector Buckets provide sub-second query responses and support operations such as cosine similarity and vector filtering. This enables developers to perform advanced searches across millions of embeddings without building a separate vector database or external infrastructure.

Being in a preview phase, these buckets come with controlled limits on the number of buckets, vector indices, and total vectors per account. The s3vector namespace is used for identification, and bucket ARNs follow a unique structure to differentiate them from standard S3 buckets.

Security is a top priority—public access is permanently disabled, and ACLs are not available. Access must be granted through IAM policies, allowing precise control over who can create, manage, or query vector indices and embeddings.

Monitoring tools such as AWS CloudTrail and Amazon CloudWatch are supported for tracking operations like index creation, vector uploads, and query performance. As organizations increasingly adopt AI and ML in production, Vector Buckets offer a native, scalable, and secure storage solution that fits seamlessly into the broader AWS ecosystem.

Following is the Tabular representation of Comparison between the Types of Amazon S3 Buckets:

Conclusion:

Selecting the appropriate S3 bucket type hinges on the nature of your application:

• General Purpose buckets offer versatile object storage for a wide range of use cases.
• Directory Buckets are ideal when ultra-low latency and zone-specific access are critical.
• Table Buckets suit scenarios involving structured, query-optimized tabular datasets.
• Vector Buckets are purpose-built for AI workloads requiring fast and accurate similarity searches across embeddings.

Each bucket type comes with its own set of constraints around naming, access, and cost, tailored to its intended use case. While monitoring, logging, and IAM-based access controls are available across all bucket types, their configurations are customized to align with the specific design and functionality of each.

References:

1. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/creating-buckets-s3.html
2. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/BucketRestrictions.html
3. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/directory-buckets-overview.html
4. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/s3-express-differences.html
5. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/s3-tables.html
6. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonS3/latest/userguide/s3-vectors.html

About CloudThat